Home
< back | 0 - 20 |  
torylltales [userpic]
Paolini: Striving to Emulate Tolkien (Comparison)
by torylltales ([info]torylltales)
at 13th July 2009 (21:59)

Paolini once said "In my writing, I strive for a lyrical beauty somewhere between Tolkien at his best and Seamus Heaney’s translation of Beowulf."

He's mentioned several times that he wanted to reach a 'lyrical beauty' comparable to Tolkien. So I thought it only fair to compare them.

Now, it's hardly fair to compare Tolkien at his best, with all his years of experience, with Paolini's best, with all his lack of experience. So to even the field, I'll compare Paolini's best to an excerpt of a letter Tolkien wrote to his son in 1944. Hardly a masterpiece of literature, right? For fairness, both excerpts feature a very similar topic/event.

LJ-Cuts Are Like Cats, Or Maybe Mules. )

ljspotlight [userpic]
Homepage Spotlight 7/13/09
by ljspotlight ([info]ljspotlight)
at 12th July 2009 (23:28)

[info]selinker
Beauty is in the eye of the beholder, and Mike Selinker's journal beholds a wide range of beautiful things, from the most beautiful arcade game to the most beautiful chase scene and even the most beautiful New Year's resolution.

ljspotlight [userpic]
Homepage Spotlight 7/13/09
by ljspotlight ([info]ljspotlight)
at 12th July 2009 (23:27)

[info]2xcreative
Have a great idea for a collaborative project but need a partner to bring your vision to life? Whether you're into interpretive knitting or photography and writing, check out this community to find the creative partner of your dreams.

ljspotlight [userpic]
Homepage Spotlight 7/13/09
by ljspotlight ([info]ljspotlight)
at 12th July 2009 (23:26)

[info]azkatraz
Harry Potter fans have a lot going on this week. Not only does The Half-Blood Prince hit movie theaters everywhere, but also the Azaktraz conference takes San Francisco by storm starting July 18. Get all the news and updates at this community.

NAHTMMM [userpic]
'Tain't home anymore, Toto
by NAHTMMM ([info]nahtmmm)
at 12th July 2009 (17:49)
relaxed

current mood: relaxed

Chapter 2.


This was rather confusing for me on the first read-through, because, based on the previous chapter, I assumed that Dezaria Johnson was going to be the main character and, therefore, the focus of this chapter. It took me quite a while to get used to the fact that Trinity was here to stay.


Me Critic Editor Insanity Jester Paranoia several


Story Or Series Title: Tainted With Memories And Scars

Rated: M for Mature (for gore and sex)
Fandom:
LotR (approx. 98% movieverse, 1.9% bookverse, and trace amounts of preservatives.)
Culprit Author's Name:
Bellethiel_Merilwen

Full Name (plus titles if any):
Trinity Erin Night.

Full Species(es): Trinity (Decambulatorian enigma): Human?
Hair Color (include adjectives): Trinity: “Her back hair was straight and long, perfectly parted”. And when the author says back hair, she probably means raven locks, judging from Chapter 4.
Eye Color (include adjectives): Trinity: “emerald” green.
Unusual Markings/Colorations: The purpose of Trinity’s existence appears to be to prove that mediocre-looking, psychotic entities can be irresistibly sexy. Or something. All the conflicting statements about her have mixed with the descriptions of the others in my head and confused me somewhat.
Special Possessions (if any): Trinity: The on/off switches for Legolas’s nostalgia for his one twu wuv. Also has someone else as well. A necklace chain thingy that has a dove with thorns, given to her by a "lover". Lotsa knives *twitch*. Intermittent paranoia or a facsimile of same. An accent that’s “untraceable” whether in NYC or Middle-earth.
Annoying Origin:
Trinity: The author’s mind.

Annoying Connections To Canon Characters:
Trinity: Obsessed over by Legolas, obsessed over by coarse!Boromir, and turns Strider’s head. Inexplicably claimed by Frodo as kin for the purpose of allowing her to enter Bree. Either has sexual relations with Haldir or stands by while he strangles in a freak accident (we’re not sure).
Annoying Special Abilities:
Trinity: Standard “jump in before the canon character” and “running mental commentary” stuff. Just WILL NOT DIE. DAGNABBIT.

Other Annoying Traits: Early on: The “sex = rite of passage to adulthood” cliché. Wallowing in the unjustified emotions of a moment. Later: Using certain Fellowship characters as foils for her main OC and often ignoring the rest. Struggling with the difference between a comma and a semi-colon; repeated neglect of the hyphen. Abusing the meaning out of “slowly”, “fine”, “evenly”, “slightly”, and other words and phrases. Most of that is tame stuff, isn’t it? I’ve killed men for less. Really? . . . No.
Non-Annoying Stuff:
Good spelling; halfway-decent grammar and mechanics aside from the punctuation. Doesn’t ignore or belittle Gimli. She does use him as her go-to character for poking fun and other less-than-noble activities (which is rather akin to how the movies treated him, so she can’t be entirely blamed).

Overall this fanfic author seems to be a fairly capable writer. However, I find parts of this just too irritating (or absurd) to let go unchallenged.



Please include a small sample of the worst of this story: (Do NOT post more than half of a chapter, whole chapters, or whole stories, regardless of how short they are)


We see Trinity pre-Bree. Whee! )

rubber_nic [userpic]
Recommended Reading
by rubber_nic ([info]rubber_nic)
at 11th July 2009 (22:31)

I just re-read the Inheritance Cycle, and I'm craving some REAL fantasy.  I've already read Harry Potter, His Dark Materials, Lord of the Rings, and Narnia.

I've heard good things about Dragonriders of Pern by Anne McCaffrey, and the Elric series by Michael Moorcock. Any opinions on these? And any other stuff I absolutely need to read?

Kyllorac [userpic]
Anti-shirt Urgal - Sketch!
by Kyllorac ([info]kyllorac)
at 11th July 2009 (17:30)

Hi there. I was hoping someone could locate a detailed description of Urgals for me (I'm pretty sure one was infodumped on us in the first book). I'd like to try my hand at rendering the anti-shirt Urgal. :D I'd look it up myself, but I don't own any of the bricks, and my local library no longer has any copies.

Thanks for the help. :D

Behold the sketchy goodness! )
On an unrelated note, am I the only one who constantly misspells Shur'tugal as Shur'tubal?

NAHTMMM [userpic]
Tainted with needles and nonsense
by NAHTMMM ([info]nahtmmm)
at 11th July 2009 (13:03)
a bit surprised

current mood: a bit surprised

Chapter 1. The prologue is sporked here.

I remembered this chapter as being unremarkable and dull. Well, I suppose it’s dull, but it’s actually quite spectacular for the amount of self-contradiction and absurdities it contains. If you do read it yourself, I recommend reading the hilarious “A Predicament” afterwards to get the bad taste out of your system.

Me Critic Editor Insanity Jester several

Story Or Series Title: Tainted With Memories And Scars

Rated: M for Mature (for gore and sex)
Fandom:
LotR (approx. 95% movieverse, 4.9% bookverse, and trace amounts of preservatives.)
Culprit Author's Name:
Bellethiel_Merilwen

Full Name (plus titles if any):
Trinity Erin Night. Other OC’s: Scarlette Rowe; Dezaria Johnson; Faith Evans; Destiny Motto
lots of OCs = an extra cut )

Non-Annoying Stuff: Good spelling; halfway-decent grammar and mechanics aside from the punctuation. Doesn’t ignore or belittle Gimli. She does use him as her go-to character for poking fun and other less-than-noble activities (which is rather akin to how the movies treated him, so she can’t be entirely blamed).

Overall this fanfic author seems to be a fairly capable writer. However, I find parts of this just too irritating (or absurd) to let go unchallenged.


Please include a small sample of the worst of this story: (Do NOT post more than half of a chapter, whole chapters, or whole stories, regardless of how short they are)

'New York City?!' 'Get the rope.' )

Psyblade [userpic]
The Ancient Language: A Mocumentery
by Psyblade ([info]derrick_mace)
at 11th July 2009 (11:32)
current location: West Tharnil Beaches
current song: Blood of Kings - In Elven Lands

The Ancient Language

The Ancient Language used to be spoken by all living things throughout the world. It used to be just what the name implies - simply a language. However, after magic had wreaked havoc in the world, a race known as The Gray Folk performed a powerful and complicated spell that bonded magic and the ancient language together, so that the former could be performed by speaking the right words in the latter without any confusion and chaos.

Now, here's the catch: Magic wreaked havoc, and all living creatures spoke it. I can imagine that being very chaotic.
But the Gray Folk had this stroke of inspiration, and bonded the magic with the language, so they can use magic by speaking the words, and use language "without any confusion and chaos."


First observation: Since all the creatures spoke the Ancient Language, transforming magic into the language would result in this: Every single creature could use magic, which is known as a destructive thing in the universe. How life formed, how creatures thrived and how societies formed is put to question, since magic was apparently so destructive, it wreaked havoc but overall didn't effect the planet negatively.

Small Text Adheres LJ's Laws )

NAHTMMM [userpic]
Tainted with purple and squick
by NAHTMMM ([info]nahtmmm)
at 10th July 2009 (21:38)
amused

current mood: amused

This was brought up by [info]calen_greenleaf recently a while ago a long while ago at some point during the Late Cretaceous Period. Anyway, since the first claimant seems to have moved on, I'm taking it on.

There are a lot of OCs (most of whom disappear for most of the story) and a lot of things going on in this looong story, so the intro sections will generally include only those relevant to the current chapter. Blame for the horrible pseudo-Latin lies with me.


Me Critic Editor Insanity Jester Violence several


Story Or Series Title: Tainted With Memories And Scars

Rated: M for Mature (for gore and sex)
Fandom: LotR (approx. 98% movieverse, 1.9% bookverse, and trace amounts of preservatives. Plus a bunch of artificial flavorings, most of which have floated to the top. This is why you stir before serving.)
Culprit Author's Name:
Bellethiel_Merilwen

Full Name (plus titles if any): Evalgine
Full Species(es): Evalgine (Speshul cutouticus): Supposedly Human.
Hair Color (include adjectives): Evalgine: I'll guess black.
Eye Color (include adjectives): Evalgine: "brilliant green"
(The author tends to identify characters by eye color, which is to say that she personifies the eyes—in fact, if this were a movie, everyone’s eyes would probably have to be paid their own wages. This can work if you don’t overdo it. Unfortunately, she overdoes it. Fortunately, eyes are the only parts of characters’ physical appearances she really overemphasizes.)
Unusual Markings/Colorations: Evalgine: Blood all over herself in the first chapter—her own blood, in fact.
Special Possessions (if any): Evalgine: A very unfortunate name and an arrow in her flesh.

Annoying Origin: Evalgine: Some Human Kingdom or another.
Annoying Connections To Canon Characters: Evalgine: The X-rated variety. Oh, did I mention she’s all of fifteen years of age?
Annoying Special Abilities: The “melodramatic death” schtick.
Other Annoying Traits: Early on: The “sex = rite of passage to adulthood” cliché. Wallowing in the emotions of a moment. Later: Struggling with the difference between a comma and a semi-colon. Repeated neglect of the hyphen. Suffocating or abusing the meaning out of “slowly”, “fine”, “evenly”, “slightly”, and other words and phrases. Most of that is tame stuff, isn’t it? I’ve killed men for less. Really? . . . No.



Non-annoying stuff )



On that note, I cannot be held responsible for misunderstandings resulting from any of Jester’s “summaries”. <_<

Please include a small sample of the worst of this story: (Do NOT post more than half of a chapter, whole chapters, or whole stories, regardless of how short they are)


A disclaimer, and then pain right from the start . . . )



Really, that’s the horrible part. Unless you like that sort of stuff, in which case it’s the fantastic part. Either way, further excerpts (and headings!) should be much shorter.

the_zuluking [userpic]
Running on Empty
by the_zuluking ([info]the_zuluking)
at 9th July 2009 (00:33)

 As a long distance runner, the part where Eragon and Narrr-GARHS-Warg run to the dwarf mountains gets a special amount of loathing from me. Using a simple calory calculator, it is easy to see just ridiculous it is. We’re going to have to assume that Eragon Human/Elf super hybrid burns energy like us humans, or else evolution or god(s) really failed us.
 
You need three things for a calory calculator. Weight, the type of activity, and the time spent performing this activity. 
 
-We’re never told Eragon weight, but being the special slender elf I’m going to make Eragon a real lightweight of 60 kg (135 lb.) Yet for some stupid reason he hauls along his sword, armour, a thick book and other random trinkets, so we’ll have to add another 40 kg, giving running Eragon a final weight of 100 kg (220lb) 

-Now for the activity. Running is usually broken down into various speeds, as running faster burns more. We get this from the book.
 
"The further he got from the sentinals, the faster he ran until he sped over the land more quickly than a galloping horse"
 
A horse gallops anywhere between 40km/h (25mph) and 48km/h (30mph,) depending on the type of horse. Regardless, no calory counter I was able to find got anywhere close to those speeds. The best I managed to find was 12 mph, so we’re going to have to work with that.  That is the speed the best human marathon runners runners are able to run at for little more than 2 hours. 
 
-Now for duration. We’re going to use the first part, since they somehow repeat this impossible feat over and over. 
 
"Eragon and Narrr-GARHS-Warg ran for the rest of the day, through the night, and the following day, stopping only to drink and relieve themselves."
 
It sounds like he runs for about a day, so 24 hours.
 
- I plug it into the calculator. A 100kg man running 12 mph for 24 hours burns 56'000 calories.  Since he is running faster than a galloping horse, he burns a grand total of 224'000 (12*4=48).
 
I grabbed this excerpt from Wikipedia
 
“If you burn 3,500 cal more than you eat, you lose about 1 pound (0.45 kg) of fat, assuming that only fat is burnt (this is close to 100% since even the waste heat counts toward the 3,500 kcal). However, energy sources can come from catabolism (breaking down) of protein (muscles), and fat may be preferentially saved. The use of different body materials as available must be considered”
 
Therefore Eragon loses almost 29 kg of body mass, and since he is the slender elf, that is pretty much all muscle. So at the end of the day, Eragon has had a crash course diet, losing almost half his body mass. 

sgarbini [userpic]
Dominus Lestrange, Chapter 1
by sgarbini ([info]sgarbini)
at 8th July 2009 (16:46)
indescribable

current location: MY HOME.
current mood: indescribable

Story Or Series Title: Dominus Lestrange and the Order of the Phoenix
Fandom: Harry Potter
Culprit Author's Name: HanzoHattoriRulez238

Full Name (plus titles if any): Dominus Lestrange
Full Species(es): Gary Stu Wizard
Hair Color (include adjectives): Dyed dark green.
Eye Color (include adjectives): I'm going to assume gray until informed otherwise.
Unusual Markings/Colorations: A headband wrapped around his arm. It is a marking. Because it's usual.
Special Possessions (if any): Black and blue robes. Like a bruise.

Annoying Origin: After being birthed by a Death Eater, he did something for fifteen years than decided to go to Hogwarts. Just for fun.
Annoying Connections To Canon Characters: Son of Bellatrix Lestrange. Cousin of the Malfoys (obviously). Eventual Ginny love-interest. Calls Ron names.
Annoying Special Abilities: Making up idiotic nicknames for people. Example: Mr. I Suffer From Foot In Mouth Disease. Speaks in Parseltongue.
Other Annoying Traits: Italicizes seductively.

Please include a small sample of the worst of this story: "Oi, Dominus, what's up with you flirting with the Weaselette?" snapped Draco.
Dominus merely flipped him the bird behind his back as he continued flirting with Ginny, who flirted back, causing Draco to pout in a very bitch girl way.




The Sporking Of Dominus )

Just testin' out a new sporkin' method.

mirandagaara [userpic]
Correction; it's like looking at a trainwreck with a whale and a bowl of petunias. O_o
by mirandagaara ([info]mirandagaara)
at 9th July 2009 (02:35)
nauseated

current location: Having a 21st century breakdown
current mood: nauseated
current song: Green Day

Story Or Series Title: http://www.quizilla.com/stories/1087958/riley-potter-witch-extraordinaire-3rd-year-part-4-secrets-revealed-a-pre-harry-tale
Fandom: Harry Potter
Culprit Author's Name: ladygaladrianna
Full Name (plus titles if any): Riley Potter
Full Species(es): Extra Sister Sparklypoo
Hair Colour (include adjectives): Not mentioned
Eye Colour (include adjectives): Silver, only she makes them look blue. Startling blue.
Unusual Markings/Colourations: A silvery ring around both retinas.
Special Possessions (if any): None
Annoying Origin: Quizilla, The Pit Of Shrews
Annoying Connections To Canon Characters: Is James' Potter's sister and best friends with the other Marauders
Annoying Special Abilities: Speshul talents that cause her to skip a grade, plus ZOMGSPESHULANGELPOWERZ. She can also do wandless magic, due to said powers.
Other Annoying Traits: Is annoyingly chirpy, plus she's half fallen angel.
Please include a small sample of the worst of this story:

In which the Sue manages to wear a bathroom. )

babycharmander [userpic]
Question...
by babycharmander ([info]babycharmander)
at 8th July 2009 (03:04)

Okay guys... this doesn't QUITE relate to the Inheritance series, but we're all fantasy fans here (or most of us are, anyway), so can someone help me out?

The reason I picked up Eragon and started reading the Inheritance series back when it first came out was because the back of the books told me it featured a dragon as one of the main characters. I was highly disappointed though when Saphira really didn't do much in the books though. I've tried looking at other fantasy books that featured dragons, but a lot of times they're either a villain, a stupid beast, or a flying horse for the main character. Or, if the dragon is one of the main characters, it's alongside a human friend. Ugh.

Are there ANY decent novels out there with a dragon as the main character and not any of the other things I mentioned? Xx;

EDIT: Oh wow, I wasn't expecting there to be quite so many books! Thanks for all the suggestions, guys! :D I'll try looking for some next time I head out to the library.

Psyblade [userpic]
The Fantasy Novelist's Exam in Inheritance
by Psyblade ([info]derrick_mace)
at 8th July 2009 (08:13)
bouncy

current mood: bouncy

Thinking about The Fantasy Novelist's Exam under Inheritance, I thought I'd post this.

   1. Does nothing happen in the first fifty pages? Yes
  LJ Cut )

the_zuluking [userpic]
Glad I stumbled across this site
by the_zuluking ([info]the_zuluking)
at 7th July 2009 (21:11)


Wow. I just stumbled across this site and I'm really happy that I did.  I've always held a special dislike for the inheritance cycle, and its good to find people who don't kiss any ground Paolini has stepped on.
I despise the books for multiple reasons, most of which it seems you guys have covered in depth already, but I'll go through the things that makes me want to head to my nearest book store, pour gasoline over a giant pile of inheritance books, and dance around like a looney while it all burns into oblivion where it belongs.

Read more... )

Read more... ).

Read more... )

Read more... )

Read more... )

Read more... )
 

Read more... )

 

</div>


 </p>

mouseycat [userpic]
Anyone else having this problem with the Eragon rewrite forum?
by mouseycat ([info]mouseycat)
at 7th July 2009 (10:19)

General Error

SQL ERROR [ mysql4 ]

Lost connection to MySQL server at 'reading initial communication packet', system error: 113 [2013]

An sql error occurred while fetching this page. Please contact an administrator if this problem persists.




... Waaaahh I want to rewrite Inhericrap not stare at error messages!

ETA: odd... it seems to be fixed.

maximuski [userpic]
Everybody loves a Ginger!, chapter 2
by maximuski ([info]maximuski)
at 6th July 2009 (16:31)
amused

current location: The Great Hall
current mood: amused
current song: Vengaboys - Boom boom boom

Story Or Series Title: Everybody loves a Ginger!

Fandom: Harry Potter and the Squealing Fangirls

Culprit Author's Name: Kendle.Cullen

Full Name (plus titles if any): Paris and Nicole Ari and Liz

Full Species(es): Muggles.

Hair Color (include adjectives):

Liz: not described

Ari: Long red hair

Eye Color (include adjectives): Not described

Unusual Markings/Colorations: none

Special Possessions (if any):

Liz: a kitten named Nessie

Annoying Origin: The Sues were watching the OotP movie, they fell asleep and woke up in the Ravenclaw Common Room.

Annoying Connections To Canon Characters: Liz weats herself over George Weasley and Ari falls for Ron.

Annoying Special Abilities: Landing into the HP world through a plasma.

Other Annoying Traits: having a hard time recognizing canon characters.

That's hawt!! )

sgarbini [userpic]
Beautiful Snake, Chapter 1
by sgarbini ([info]sgarbini)
at 5th July 2009 (21:05)
bitchy

current mood: bitchy

Story Or Series Title: Beautiful Snake
Fandom: Harry Potter
Culprit Author's Name: revengeisfun

Full Name (plus titles if any): Belinda Elizabeth Cloude
Full Species(es): Human. Barely.
Hair Color (include adjectives): Long, sleek and black.
Eye Color (include adjectives): Icy blue, exactly the same color as Draco's.
Unusual Markings/Colorations: None.
Special Possessions (if any): A golden, goblin made locket... purple socks... a box of chocolate... a bouquet of roses... a delicate golden ring (inset with an emerald) ... and beautiful sea green dress robes.

Annoying Origin: Born in America to negligent parents. Kicked out of Salem Institute because she "didn't belong." Transferred to Hogwarts and sorted into - you guessed it - Slytherin.
Annoying Connections To Canon Characters: Family friend to the Malfoys, love interest of Draco, friend of the Weasley twins and eventually the Trio. Pansy's nemesis, Blaise Zabini's little friend.
Annoying Special Abilities: Amazing singing voice, ability to win over any male in a three mile radius.
Other Annoying Traits: Whiny and wannabe funny.

Please include a small sample of the worst of this story: As she examined her recently painted nails, black, a bouquet of roses in the trash caught her eye. “Who in their right mind throws away roses?” There was a note attached to the roses, which said: Bell, as my plan didn’t work, I apologize for acting like a jerk. The script became more rushed and angry looking. You know what, screw that. I give up. This is either going to work, or I’m not going to talk to her. Screw the roses.
She laughed to herself, and then sat back down and resumed examining her nails. They were stubby and recently cut, and the black polish stood out against her magically tanned skin.



May the sporking begin... )




aztec_the_great [userpic]
Defy not the sporkers!
by aztec_the_great ([info]aztec_the_great)
at 5th July 2009 (14:01)
cranky

current location: SSV Spork
current mood: cranky
current song: Dark Knight


Story Or Series Title: Defy Not the Heart
Fandom: Harry Potter and the Sparkly Vampires from
Pretty Land
Culprit Author's Name: Aewnaur
Synopsis:

Slash: EC/HP
Warnings: abuse violence
Summary: Harry comes to Forks as a patient for Dr. Cullen. He was only supposed to stay until he healed enough to go back to the war. Will he discover a reason to stay?

Full Name (plus titles if any): Harry Potter/Jonquil Kaolin/Jon and Edward Cullen
Hair Color (include adjectives): Harry has “His black hair was a wild dirty mane but he could see where the dark red would highlight it”

Eye Color (include adjectives): So far not described

Unusual Markings/Colorations: Harry is “Tiny and very feminine yet with a strong masculine jaw and physique.”
Special Possessions (if any): Apparently, each other’s balls in future


Annoying Origin: The warped brain of a Twihard HP fan
Annoying Special Abilities: existing

Other Traits:

Harry will be “truly extraordinary when he was healed”

Harry gave up part of his humanity to weaken Voldemort, so he isn’t all human anymore

Lilly apparently had creature blood in her lineage so Harry never was completely human to start off with.

Read more... )

< back | 0 - 20 |